Hiring New Graduates as Day-One Managers in the Age of AI
With artificial intelligence performing traditional entry-level knowledge work, new college graduates face hiring challenges. Experts argue the solution is training young professionals to become day-one managers who direct AI agents using core leadership skills.

Recently, during a lakeside conversation, the head of AI for a pharmaceutical company remarked on the incredible productivity his senior team extracts from artificial intelligence.
He then paused and posed a critical question: “You know, I may never hire another junior engineer again. Which is great for the business right now, but who’s the next generation that is going to run this when we retire?”
This anxiety over the future of young professionals entering the workforce carries a profound human weight. The concern extends beyond mere employment rates to ask what becomes of our students and children.
College graduates historically handle the individual contributor knowledge work that AI is increasingly capable of performing. For instance, a recent Stanford study highlights that employment for 22- to 25-year-olds in occupations most vulnerable to AI is trailing rates for peers in less impacted sectors by 19%, a gap that continues to grow.
What function will fresh graduates serve in an AI-driven economy? And how will we cultivate the next cohort of managers to oversee AI? Fortunately, we have 200 years of historical examples showing how to teach 22-year-olds to achieve precisely that.
Our argument is that senior professionals excel with AI today not primarily due to superior subject matter expertise, but because they are skilled managers. They must trust subordinates without placing blind faith in them, divide tasks, delegate clearly, review results, and patiently correct, coach, and occasionally reassign personnel.
The path forward for new graduates involves becoming effective managers immediately at the start of their careers, rather than waiting until after a lengthy tenure as individual contributors.
The craft of management
AI’s core innovation is its capacity to deliver knowledge work. Given our deep familiarity with human knowledge workers, the parallel to AI knowledge workers is robust.
Knowledge workers typically possess far deeper expertise in their specialized domains than their managers do. Effective managers routinely organize and lead knowledge workers who are significantly more intelligent than they are, utilizing the craft of management.
As AI systems increasingly function like AI executives, these exact leadership qualities provide capable managers with the necessary skills to direct AI agents acting as individual contributor knowledge workers.
Investment industry culture notoriously prioritizes the brilliance of the individual contributor who delivers sharp insights, makes correct investment calls, and closes one-on-one negotiations successfully.
Having lived within this culture for years, I know that calling an investor a “great people manager” serves as a backhanded compliment at best. In this sector, the transition from individual contributor to manager typically occurs midcareer or later, often with little to no formal management training.
Analysts, associates, and vice presidents function primarily as individual contributors—while occasionally mentoring junior staff—and do not transition into primary managers of other knowledge workers until reaching the principal or partner level.
Years ago during my time as an analyst at Morgan Stanley, the hierarchy stretched from analyst to managing director. Analysts stood as the ultimate individual contributors, and whenever one attempted to delegate tasks, we used a specific label: “managing analyst.” This dismissive moniker reflected the cultural conviction that true credit belongs to those who execute the work personally, not those who achieve results through others.
What happens without management
This blind spot regarding the value of management extends far beyond the investment industry. Consider the recent OpenAI-Hugging Face incident, in which OpenAI agents hacked into Hugging Face, as another prominent example.
In its official report on the breach, OpenAI proposed a lengthy remediation list—including heightened security, breach alerts, and post-incident reviews—while failing to directly address training employees to better manage these agents. This oversight occurred even though internal OpenAI team members had flagged concerning behaviors, such as message board and unauthorized internet activity, as early as late May without taking action until July.
While potentially an imperfect analogy, imagine hiring 1,200 workers for a warehouse complex, providing detailed written instructions, and sending all line and senior managers away for a week. Discovering a stolen delivery van upon return would not point to hiring the wrong workers or giving unclear instructions; the root failure would be a lack of management.
Accelerated leadership development
While grappling with this dilemma, I consulted business school classmate Michael Quoia, a U.S. Naval Academy graduate and former officer who built a career in executive leadership development. He shared:
“When I met my division of 25 sailors in Yokosuka, Japan at the young age of 22 years old, I was greeted by my senior chief petty officer, who already served for nearly 20 years. Behind him, we had several organizational levels including the first line sailors who conducted maintenance on the fire control systems. This was actually a harder problem than we are facing with AI. This was about supervising at least three levels without experience. I was expected to provide character, judgment, problem solving and leadership, despite not having come up through the ranks. How did the Navy develop these qualities in me so that I could bypass time in the seat as a frontline worker?”
Much like corporations confronting the AI challenge, the military must develop capable leaders who lack entry-level operational experience. Although the military offers a highly relevant model, it is not singular. Programs like The Home Depot’s store management track and General Electric’s Crotonville demonstrate how corporations recruit high-potential talent and subject them to accelerated leadership development to prepare them for managing unfamiliar roles.
Examining how the Naval Academy structured Michael’s training reveals valuable lessons for 22-year-olds and those hiring them.
First, cultivating future officers begins with building moral leadership. The mission of the United States Naval Academy opens with the goal “To develop midshipmen morally, mentally, and physically … .” In the era of AI, first-line managers of AI agents will require integrity and a solid moral compass, as artificial intelligence lacks pre-installed ethics. Moral leadership regarding AI carries profound societal implications and demands deliberate development.
Second, service academies function intentionally as leadership laboratories. From plebe summer to commissioning, midshipmen advance from learning subordination to mastering management. Crucially for the AI age, simulated leadership training is both viable and proven when carefully designed.
Third, service academies integrate high-pressure scenarios into their leadership training. Although most companies do not place first-line managers in life-or-death situations, leading through high-stakes events—such as taking personal responsibility for a rogue AI agent swarm—requires composure and decisive action under stress.
Bring back the ‘managing analyst’
If a 22-year-old ensign can manage 25 sailors on a Yokosuka destroyer with the backing of senior officers and enlisted personnel, our 22-year-old college graduates can certainly be trained to oversee 25 super-intelligent agents. Across knowledge work industries, the practice of management must shift from age 32 down to age 22.
In short, we must resurrect the “managing analyst.” We need to acknowledge that AI agents function as knowledge workers and therefore require active management. Knowledge-work industries must reset their cultures to value management as a core skill from the start of a career rather than at the midcareer mark.
Entry-level workers are intelligent, driven, quick to learn, and hard-working. A massive, unmet demand exists for management skills to harness this new generation of AI agents. Service academies have proven across nearly two centuries that these capabilities can be successfully imparted to the young. For college graduates, the future demands redefining their roles away from individual-contributor knowledge work and toward effective management and leadership from day one.
Bob Morse co-founded Strattam Capital in 2014 and is managing partner. He has served on numerous private and public technology company boards, and currently is a director of CloudHesive, Contegix, Daxtra Technologies, Green Security, Resource Navigation and Trax Group. Previously, he was a partner and member of the investment committee at Oak Hill Capital Partners. He also worked at GCC Investments and Morgan Stanley. Morse serves on the board of directors of Austin PBS and as member of the advisory board for the HMTF Center for Private Equity Finance at The University of Texas at Austin McCombs School of Business. He attended Princeton University, graduating summa cum laude with a BSE, and Stanford Graduate School of Business, where he earned his MBA and was an Arjay Miller Scholar. Morse lives in Austin.
Michael Quoia is co-founder and partner at KSE Leadership, which assesses and develops leaders and teams. A 25-year leadership advisory veteran with partner-level roles at Heidrick & Struggles and Russell Reynolds Associates, he began his career as a U.S. Navy surface warfare officer. He is a graduate of the U.S. Naval Academy and holds an MBA from the Stanford Graduate School of Business.
Related Crunchbase query:
- Global Venture Funding To AI Startups In 2026
Related reading:
- AI-Native, Not AI-Sprinkle: Why AI Is A Business Change, Not A Technology Change
- SaaS Is Dead. Long Live SaaS! AI And The End Of The Rationing Of Knowledge Work
- Don’t Just Talk About AI. Measure Business Outputs. Here’s How.
- The Rise Of The AI Executive
Illustration: Dom Guzman
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are new college graduates struggling to find entry-level knowledge work jobs in the AI era?
College graduates traditionally perform individual contributor knowledge work that AI is increasingly capable of delivering. A recent Stanford study highlights that employment for 22- to 25-year-olds in AI-exposed occupations is running 19% below peers in less impacted sectors.
How does good management relate to working with AI systems?
Senior professionals succeed with AI not just through subject knowledge, but because they possess management skills—such as trusting workers without complete oversight, dividing tasks, delegating clearly, reviewing results, and coaching.
What is the concept of bringing back the “managing analyst”?
It involves redefining entry-level knowledge work jobs so that recent graduates act as effective managers and leaders of AI agents from the very beginning of their careers rather than waiting until midcareer.
How do military service academies offer a model for early leadership?
Institutions like the U.S. Naval Academy train 22-year-olds to lead diverse teams, build moral leadership, utilize leadership laboratories, and handle high-pressure scenarios without prior frontline operational experience.
Can leadership skills really be taught to young professionals early on?
Yes, historical examples from the military and corporate accelerated leadership programs like GE’s Crotonville and The Home Depot demonstrate that simulated leadership learning and early management can be successfully taught to young talent.




Comments 0 responses